Low aerial view across a calm lake toward pale coastal homes with metal roofs, palms and native preserve landscaping in Southwest Florida.

What an Isles of Collier Preserve Home Costs Now That Minto Has Sold Out

Ten homes closed in Isles of Collier Preserve in September 2026, at a median of $1.02 million. In October, nine closed at a median of $1.92 million. Read on its own, that is an 88.5% jump in one month, in a guard-gated community of 1,825 homes four miles from Fifth Avenue South.

October's median reflects which homes closed that month. Six of the nine October sales were single-family homes, at a median of $2.22 million. The other three were villas and townhomes, at a median of $725,000. In this community, the headline median mostly tells you how the month's sales split between those two kinds of homes. If you are comparing Isles of Collier Preserve with other Naples communities, the number to work from is the price for the home type you would actually buy.

The builder's price list is gone

For about 12 years, Minto set a reference price for the community. On March 3, 2026, Minto announced that it had sold the last new home at The Isles of Collier Preserve. That release dates the community's opening to 2014 and puts the final count at 1,825 homes, including 229 added after Minto bought another 103 acres in 2022.

The builder's price sheet used to give buyers a fixed point. Minto's community brochure, printed in March 2024, advertised the "final phase now selling" with new homes from the $500s. Eight months after the sellout, every sale is a resale between owners. Nobody publishes a base price, and the only public reference is whatever closed recently. In a community this varied, "recently" can mean a 1,200-square-foot cottage one week and a 4,000-square-foot home on a 90-foot lot the next.

A year of medians that move with the mix

Here is the past year in Southwest Florida MLS closed sales, month by month, from November 2025 through October 2026:

Month Homes sold Median price Median $/sq ft Median days on market
Nov 2025 4 $875K $531 31
Dec 2025 7 $770K $494 20
Jan 2026 7 $852K $464 47
Feb 2026 15 $1.69M $607 40
Mar 2026 15 $1.71M $675 91
Apr 2026 19 $1.01M $542 34
May 2026 17 $958K $545 35
Jun 2026 14 $788K $503 47
Jul 2026 9 $1.5M $690 116
Aug 2026 14 $1.04M $503 111
Sep 2026 10 $1.02M $515 70
Oct 2026 9 $1.92M $710 8

Within 12 months, the median ran from $770,000 to $1.92 million and back several times. Price per square foot didn't steady the picture either. It rose and fell almost in step with the median: $464 in January, $675 in March, $503 in June, $690 in July and $710 in October. In October, the one month here with a published split, the single-family homes made up two-thirds of sales and both figures hit their highs for the year.

Over the full year, the picture settles. In the 12 months through October 27, 2026, 140 homes closed at a median of $1,027,500. Prices ranged from $470,000 to $4.25 million, and the largest single price band, about a third of all sales, fell between $700,000 and $1 million. Over that year, homes took a median of 44 days to sell and closed at 96% of list price. That annual median is real, but it is the middle of a range that runs from paired villas to estate homes, not the price of any typical house.

Four kinds of homes, four price levels

Minto built the community in phases and collections of home designs. It never laid out named neighborhoods, so home type is the clearest way to sort it. Homes built from 2014 to 2026 fall into four formats.

Coastal Cottages are the price floor. They run 1,204 to 1,466 square feet, with two bedrooms, two baths, front porches and rear-entry garages. When Naples Daily News introduced the collection in February 2022, the plans were the Marco, Sanibel, Useppa and Captiva. When the models opened, Naples Daily News reported in July 2022 that the first release started in the $500s.

The Buttonwood Collection paired villas, roughly 1,560 to 1,864 square feet, make up the largest share of sales and fill most of the $700,000 to $1 million band. Minto's 2024 brochure lists the villa plans by living area: Dahlia at 1,560 square feet, Petunia at 1,618, Mimosa at 1,782 and Fresia at 1,864. These were the homes Minto was still building at the end. Gulfshore Business reported that the 103-acre addition along Bayshore Drive was planned as 138 paired villas and 91 detached single-family homesites.

Coach homes in the Sabal and Cypress Collections run about 1,621 to 2,960 square feet over one to three stories, and several have private elevators. The Dominica Isle coach homes are the only condominium ownership in the community.

Single-family homes make up the top of the market. These are Minto's Palmetto and Mangrove Collections and Stock Signature Homes' Magnolia and Cottonwood Collections, about 2,016 to 4,327 square feet on lots up to 90 feet wide, facing lakes, waterways and preserve. Stock's early pricing gives a sense of how far this segment has moved. In February 2016, Naples Daily News reported base prices for the Magnolia Collection on 90-foot homesites: the Marigold at 3,578 square feet for $839,990, the Cocoplum at $849,990, the Plumbago at $859,990 and the 3,972-square-foot Viola at $899,990. Those are decade-old base prices before lot premiums and options. In October 2026, the single-family median was $2.22 million, and the two sales above $3 million had a median of $3.35 million.

October's sales break down along the same lines. Two homes sold between $500,000 and $1 million, at a median of $655,000. Five sold between $1 million and $3 million, at a median of $1.92 million, and two sold above $3 million. With nine sales spread across those three bands, the month's median landed on a single home in the middle one.

The club is the same at every price

Because the club comes with every home, the price gap between formats comes almost entirely from the house and the lot. The Isles Club is paid for through master association dues, with no initiation fee, no membership tiers and no separate club bill. A paired-villa owner and an estate-home owner get the same clubhouse, resort pool and lap pool, Fins Up! fitness center, tennis, pickleball and bocce courts, and the Overlook Bar & Grill on the Cypress Waterway, which is open to residents Thursday through Sunday. Every owner can also use more than eight miles of trails named for local birds, from Sandpiper to Cormorant, and the 1.5-mile Snook Kayak Trail, with kayaks loaned free from the boathouse.

The community has no golf course and no marina. Residents who want Gulf access can join the neighboring Hamilton Harbor Yacht Club on Naples Bay, which is optional and priced separately from association dues. When you compare this community with golf or boating communities elsewhere in Naples, those extra costs belong on the other side of the comparison.

Carrying costs follow home type much less than prices do. The property owners association's FY2025 budget lists quarterly assessments from $1,407.25 for coach homes to $1,957.76 for single-family homes on 90-foot lots. Paired villas are $1,593.59, coastal villas $1,545.88, and 50-, 62- and 75-foot single-family lots $1,525.64, $1,559.43 and $1,622.22. The community has no CDD. Dominica Isle coach homes also pay a separate condominium assessment. Many current listings show higher quarterly figures than that budget schedule, so confirm the current assessment for the specific home you are considering. These figures are general information, not legal, tax or financial advice, so please confirm your own costs with the right professional.

What the current listings say

Today, 56 homes are listed in the community at a median asking price of $1.1 million. At the sales pace of the past three months, that is about 5.1 months of supply. Selling speed varied as much as price this year. The median home took 111 days to sell in August and 8 days in October, and October sales closed at 97.9% of list price.

When you compare a listing here, check it against recent sales of the same format and size: paired villa against paired villa, 75-foot lot against 75-foot lot. Measured against the community median, a cottage looks like a bargain and an estate home looks overpriced, and both readings are wrong. The same rule applies across Naples. In The Moorings, bridge-free water access splits one waterfront market into several. In Isles of Collier Preserve, home type does the splitting.

FAQ

Can I still buy new construction from Minto in Isles of Collier Preserve? No. Minto announced on March 3, 2026 that it had sold the last new home in the community, so every home for sale now is a resale.

What is a typical price in Isles of Collier Preserve? It depends on the type of home. Over the 12 months through October 27, 2026, the median for the whole community was $1,027,500, and about a third of sales fell between $700,000 and $1 million. In October 2026 alone, the median was $725,000 for villas and townhomes and $2.22 million for single-family homes.

Is there a club initiation fee? No. The Isles Club is included in the master association dues, with no initiation fee and no membership tiers.

If you are weighing a paired villa against a single-family home in Isles of Collier Preserve, or would like to know how your own home compares with recent sales of the same type since Minto sold out, Linda Kennedy would be glad to look at the sales for that format with you. You can request a home valuation or explore the Isles of Collier Preserve neighborhood page. Let's Connect.

Get Started Today

Her tailored marketing strategies, extensive network, and strong negotiation skills consistently deliver results, whether she's guiding a first-time buyer or representing a multi-million dollar estate. She is the advisor you want by your side when navigating the Naples real estate market.

Follow Me on Instagram